ONE of the infernal questions: what is art?
Well, ‘art’ is a word that was once upon a time applied to such things as paintings, ceramics and sculpture. Subsequent generations asked, ‘No, really, what is art?’ and the word garnered near mystical speculation over its essence and true meaning. After centuries of that we are more likely to ask, ‘What isn’t art?’
The neighbouring picture will offer no illumination. The pianist, Strungoff Vortex, whose asteroid-based hermitage suffered a system failure and slowly radiated over an 8 month period until what happens to all of us eventually happened to him. On one occasion a child erected their cracked lollipop into the head of our pianist. The parents were suitably mortified but we all found it rather funny, so we left it in.
Accompanying the exhibit we had the music Strungoff recorded while he died (and a few preceding months for reference’s sake), which is a lifetime of listening. His highlights compilation, ‘Music Recorded While Dying of Radiation’, was a popular novelty present for music aficionados.
Whether considered ‘good’ or ‘bad’, art refl ects the artist, as well as the reality and zeitgeist that surrounds them. There are times when art makers desire intrinsic meaning, or prize virtuosity, or need money and see a way of getting it. Value is often found by those who identify most closely with the artist. Thus, alas, art returns to the eye of the beholder.
What seems ridiculous about these meandering art arguments is the initial idea that there could ever be universal agreement* when even individual words can be hotly contested and skewed by personal context – how could visual stimulus be bound to some conformity of understanding? That would require a conformity in thinking and perspective; the removal of the individual in fact.
One could apply that theory to any discrepancy between people – but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try to agree. And thus art and discussion have persisted; perhaps the human essence lies between rather than inside us.
* Or even just on Earth!